Questions to Ask a Fractional CMO Before You Sign
Quick answer: Before you sign, ask a fractional CMO for real estate results you can verify, what they would look at first, the number they will own and by when, who owns your accounts and work, how the engagement ends, and whether any vendor they recommend pays them. The full list below is grouped by what each question protects, with what a strong answer sounds like.
On this page: Why ask · Fit · How they start · Results · Real estate rules · Contract · Money and conflicts · References · Red flags · Checklist
Why the questions matter
The number of people calling themselves fractional leaders has grown fast. Harvard Business Review reported that about 2,000 LinkedIn users had “fractional” in their titles in 2022, and more than 110,000 by early 2024. Anyone can add the word. The questions below separate a leader who will own your marketing results from a consultant who will hand you a deck.
Start with the basics. What a fractional CMO does and what one costs cover the role and price ranges. This guide is the list to bring to the call.
Fit and experience
| Question | A strong answer | Worry if |
|---|---|---|
| 1. What have you done for a real estate team or brokerage? | Named results in recruiting, lead flow, brand or listing marketing, with numbers | Only other industries, or “marketing is marketing” |
| 2. Walk me through one engagement from start to finish. | The situation, what they found, what they changed and what moved | A highlight reel with no problem or process |
| 3. What was your biggest miss, and what did you learn? | A real example and what they do differently now | “Every engagement went great,” or a story where the client was the problem |
| 4. Do you work with a competing team or brokerage in our market? | A clear yes or no, and how they handle it | Hesitation, or “it won’t matter” |
| 5. Who else are you working with right now, and how many clients? | A number that leaves real time for you | More clients than they can name |
How they would start
| Question | A strong answer | Worry if |
|---|---|---|
| 6. What would you look at first in our business? | Your numbers: lead sources, routing, conversion, recruiting and spend | A new logo, website or content plan before seeing any data |
| 7. What will we have at 30, 60 and 90 days? | A short audit, a plan with priorities, then first changes live and measured | A fixed package that looks the same for every client |
| 8. How many hours a month, and how will we meet? | A set amount of time and a meeting rhythm, usually weekly or every other week | “As needed” with no structure |
| 9. What do you need from us? | Specific access, data, decisions and a point person | Nothing, which usually means they plan to work around your team |
Results and reporting
| Question | A strong answer | Worry if |
|---|---|---|
| 10. What number will you own, and by when? | One or two metrics tied to revenue or recruiting, with a target and a review date | Followers, impressions or “brand awareness” alone |
| 11. How will you measure lead sources? | Cost per lead, per appointment and per closing by source, plus cost per recruited agent | Platform dashboards only |
| 12. What does your monthly report show? | Spend, results, what changed, what is next | A slide deck of activity |
| 13. Who approves ad spend and new vendors? | You approve budgets and contracts; they recommend and run | They want open-ended authority over your card |
| 14. How do you run paid social? | Real campaigns in Meta Ads Manager or Google Ads with a goal, audience and tracking | The Boost button |
The Team Marketing Budget spreadsheet tracks cost per closing by source, so you can hold any CMO to the same numbers.
Real estate rules
A real estate CMO should answer these without looking anything up.
| Question | A strong answer | Worry if |
|---|---|---|
| 15. How do you keep our ads within fair housing rules? | Ad review for words, images and targeting; knows Meta’s special ad category for housing; knows the Fair Housing Act still applies even after HUD withdrew its 2024 digital advertising guidance | “Meta handles that” |
| 16. What do our state’s advertising and team-name rules require? | Knows brokerage name and team rules in your state, or checks the commission’s rules before launching anything | Has never heard of them |
| 17. How would you structure co-marketing with a lender or title partner? | Each side pays its fair share, with a written agreement reviewed under RESPA | “Lenders pay for everything” |
| 18. What are the rules for texting and calling leads? | Consent for automated texts and calls, honoring opt-outs, Do Not Call rules and stricter state laws | No answer, or “everyone texts” |
| 19. Are you licensed, and does that change how you can be paid? | Clear on what they can and cannot do, and why pay tied to closings needs review | Wants a share of commissions without asking about license law |
On question 19: many states bar licensees from paying referral or finder’s fees to unlicensed people, and rules vary by state. Have your broker or attorney review any pay tied to closings or referrals.
Our compliance guides cover each area: fair housing, state advertising rules, team naming, RESPA and texting and calling.
Contract terms
| Question | A strong answer | Worry if |
|---|---|---|
| 20. What exactly is included each month, and what costs extra? | A written scope with deliverables, meetings and response times | “We’ll figure it out as we go” |
| 21. What is the minimum term, and how much notice to end it? | A clear minimum and notice period in writing | Long lock-ins with no exit |
| 22. Who owns the work you create? | You do, through a written assignment of rights | They keep ownership of plans, content or templates made for you |
| 23. Who owns our ad, social, website and CRM accounts? | You do. Accounts sit under your business and billing, with the CMO given access | Accounts in their agency’s name or on their card |
| 24. Will you sign a confidentiality agreement? | Yes, covering your client data, agent data and numbers | Pushback |
| 25. Do you use subcontractors or AI tools on our work? | Names who does what, and how client data is protected | Surprises later |
Ownership of the work. A “work made for hire” label alone often does not transfer ownership from a contractor. The U.S. Copyright Office explains that commissioned work qualifies only if both sides sign a written agreement and the work fits one of nine specific categories. Ask for a clause that assigns all rights to you as well.
Accounts. If your ad account sits inside a contractor’s business account, you can lose its history, audiences and tracking data when the contract ends. Create every account under your business first, then grant access.
Contractor status. A fractional CMO is usually an independent contractor. The IRS weighs behavioral control, financial control and the relationship of the parties. The U.S. Department of Labor proposed a new contractor rule in February 2026 that weighs control and opportunity for profit or loss most heavily; check its status with your accountant or attorney.
Term. Each CMO sets their own terms. A 6-month minimum is common for the build stage, and many engagements run 12 to 24 months before moving to a lighter advisory retainer that can end on 30 days notice.
Money and conflicts
| Question | A strong answer | Worry if |
|---|---|---|
| 26. Do you receive commissions, referral fees or affiliate payments from any vendor you might recommend? | A clear list, in writing, or a clear no | Vague answers, or a CRM or lead source picked before they have seen your setup |
| 27. Is ad spend separate from your fee? | Yes. Ad spend is billed to your accounts directly | Ad spend run through their invoice with a markup you cannot see |
| 28. What happens to unused hours? | A clear rule, such as hours do not roll over or roll over for one month | No answer |
| 29. How does this engagement end? | A handoff plan to a full-time hire, your team or a lighter retainer, with documentation | No plan for leaving |
On question 26: a disclosed relationship can be fine. The FTC’s Endorsement Guides require material connections, including commissions, to be disclosed when someone promotes a product publicly. Private advice to a client is a contract matter, so put the disclosure in your agreement.
Pricing context: fractional CMOs for real estate teams commonly charge $3,000 to $15,000+ a month, with most engagements between $5,000 and $12,000, and $3,000 to $5,000 at the advisory level. The cost guide breaks it down.
How to check references
Ask for two or three clients, including at least one past client. Then ask them:
- What did they change in the first 90 days?
- What number moved, and how much?
- How did they handle a disagreement or a miss?
- How did the engagement end?
- Would you hire them again?
Check that the results they claimed match what the reference describes.
Red flags
- Recommending channels, tools or a rebrand before seeing your numbers
- Promising a set number of leads or recruits
- Leading with their rate instead of the problem they would solve
- No real estate clients, or no knowledge of fair housing, RESPA or license law
- Accounts or ad spend run through their business
- No references, or only current clients
- Every story a success, or every failure the client’s fault
- No plan for how the engagement ends
- Recommending the Boost button
The checklist
Copy this into your notes for the call.
- What have you done for a real estate team or brokerage?
- Walk me through one engagement start to finish.
- What was your biggest miss?
- Do you work with a competitor in our market?
- How many clients do you have now?
- What would you look at first?
- What will we have at 30, 60 and 90 days?
- How many hours a month, and how will we meet?
- What do you need from us?
- What number will you own, and by when?
- How will you measure lead sources?
- What does your monthly report show?
- Who approves ad spend and vendors?
- How do you run paid social?
- How do you keep ads within fair housing rules?
- What do our state’s advertising and team-name rules require?
- How would you structure lender co-marketing?
- What are the rules for texting and calling leads?
- Are you licensed, and how does that affect pay?
- What is included, and what costs extra?
- What is the minimum term and notice?
- Who owns the work?
- Who owns our accounts?
- Will you sign a confidentiality agreement?
- Do you use subcontractors or AI tools?
- Do vendors pay you?
- Is ad spend separate from your fee?
- What happens to unused hours?
- How does this end?
Not sure you need a CMO yet? Fractional CMO vs marketing director compares the options, and the free Brokerage Marketing Audit shows where your marketing stands today.
Key takeaways
- Ask for real estate results you can verify, and call past clients.
- A strong CMO starts with your numbers and owns a metric with a date.
- They should know fair housing, state advertising rules, RESPA and texting rules.
- You own the accounts, the ad spend and the work. Put it in the contract.
- Ask whether vendors pay them, and get the answer in writing.
- Agree on how the engagement ends before it starts.
Sources
Show all 10 sources
- Harvard Business Review, How part-time senior leaders can help your business (2024)
- Forbes Business Council, Fractional executives aren’t consultants (2026) (contributor content)
- U.S. Copyright Office, Circular 30: Works made for hire
- Internal Revenue Service, Independent contractor or employee
- U.S. Department of Labor, Proposed rule on employee or independent contractor status (2026)
- Federal Register, FTC Guides concerning endorsements and testimonials (2023)
- Federal Register, Withdrawal of fair housing guidance documents (2026)
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, RESPA FAQs
- Federal Communications Commission, Removal of the one-to-one consent rule
- Idaho Real Estate Commission, Guideline on referral and finder’s fees
Frequently asked questions
What is the most important question to ask a fractional CMO?
Ask what number they will own, by when. A strong candidate names a metric that matters to your business, such as cost per closing, appointments set or agents recruited, and a date to review it. Vague answers about awareness or engagement are a warning sign.
Should a fractional CMO have real estate experience?
For a team or brokerage, yes. Real estate marketing runs on rules most industries never deal with: fair housing advertising, state license law, RESPA, team naming rules and lead follow-up laws. A CMO without that background learns it on your budget.
Who should own our ad accounts and social media accounts?
You should. Ad accounts, Facebook Pages, Instagram accounts, the website, the domain and the CRM should be created under your business, billed to your card, with the CMO given access. Ownership should not change when the engagement ends.
What contract length is normal for a fractional CMO?
Terms vary by provider, and each CMO sets their own. A 6-month minimum is common for the build stage, and many engagements run 12 to 24 months before moving to a lighter advisory retainer that can end on 30 days notice.
Is it a problem if a fractional CMO earns commissions from vendors they recommend?
It can be. Ask directly whether they receive referral fees, commissions or affiliate payments from any CRM, lead source, website or ad vendor, and put the answer in writing. A disclosed relationship can be fine. An undisclosed one is a conflict.