Reviews and Testimonials: FTC Rules for Real Estate Teams
Quick answer: Since October 21, 2024, the FTC’s Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule bans fake reviews, buying reviews, undisclosed insider reviews, incentives tied to positive sentiment and review suppression, with civil penalties up to $53,088 per violation. Google adds its own bans on review incentives, review gating and conflict-of-interest reviews. Ask every closed client for an honest review, the same way, with no reward tied to the rating.
This is general information, not legal advice. Check with your broker or an attorney before you change a review program, especially one that uses gifts or a review vendor.
On this page: Why it matters · The FTC rule · Endorsement Guides · Platform rules · License law · Asking the right way · Penalties
Why reviews are a compliance issue
Reviews drive agent selection, recruiting and local search. They also create risk when a team runs them like a campaign: review swaps between agents, a gift card for “5 stars,” a script that steers unhappy clients away from Google, or a testimonial page that quotes clients who never said it.
The FTC’s rule is federal and applies to every business, including brokerages and teams. Platform rules sit on top of it and can remove reviews or suspend a profile without any regulator involved. The person who owns marketing on a team owns this risk, whether that is the team leader, a marketing generalist or a fractional CMO. See Who Should Own Marketing on a Real Estate Team? if that role is unclear on your team.
What the FTC rule bans
The Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (16 CFR Part 465) took effect October 21, 2024. The parts that matter for a team:
| Practice | What the rule says |
|---|---|
| Fake or false reviews | You may not write, buy or post reviews or testimonials by someone who does not exist, who had no real experience with you, or that misstate the reviewer’s experience. AI-generated fake reviews count. |
| Buying reviews | You may not pay for or give incentives for reviews that are fake or false. |
| Incentives tied to sentiment | You may not give anything conditioned, directly or by implication, on the review being positive (or negative). |
| Insider reviews | A review by an officer or manager, or their relatives, must clearly disclose the connection. Officers and managers may not ask employees or agents for reviews, or ask them to collect reviews from relatives, without the right disclosures. |
| Company-controlled review sites | You may not run a “review” site that looks independent but is controlled by you. |
| Review suppression | You may not use unfounded legal threats, physical threats, intimidation or public false accusations to stop or remove a review, or claim the reviews on your site show all or most reviews when you have hidden negative ones. |
| Fake social influence | You may not buy or sell fake followers or views to inflate your influence for a commercial purpose. |
The rule does not bar asking customers for reviews, and it does not bar every incentive. It bars incentives tied to sentiment and reviews that misrepresent who wrote them or what happened.
Endorsements, disclosures and material connections
The FTC’s revised Endorsement Guides (16 CFR Part 255, published in July 2023) explain how disclosures work. They apply to testimonials, reviews and influencer posts:
- Material connections must be disclosed. If a connection between the reviewer and the business would change how people weigh the review, and the audience would not expect it, disclose it clearly. Family, employment, payment, free products and gifts all count.
- Disclosures must be clear and conspicuous. Put them in the review or post itself, in plain words, not in a profile bio or a link.
- Testimonials must reflect typical results or say what results people can generally expect. “Sold in 3 days for $40,000 over asking” from one client, with no context, can imply results most clients will not get.
- Advertisers are responsible for what their endorsers say on their behalf, including agents and paid creators who promote the team.
For brokerages that recruit with agent testimonials, the same rules apply. A “why I joined” video from an agent who got a signing bonus should say so. See Agent Attraction Content: What Top Recruiting Brokerages Post for how recruiting content is usually built.
Google, Zillow and Realtor.com rules
Google. Google’s Maps user contributed content policy is stricter than the FTC rule:
- No incentives of any kind (payment, discounts, free goods or services) for posting a review or for changing or removing a negative one.
- No review gating. Businesses may not discourage negative reviews or selectively solicit positive ones, which rules out “happy? leave a Google review; unhappy? tell us privately” funnels.
- No conflict-of-interest reviews. Owners, current and former employees and competitors may not review the business. Agents reviewing their own brokerage or each other’s Google profiles fall into this.
- Fake engagement is removed, and violations can lead to removed reviews, profile restrictions or suspension.
Zillow. Zillow lets agents request reviews from past clients through its review request tool, screens reviews before publishing, and uses MLS data to connect reviews to transactions. Zillow says it may terminate an agent’s profile and related programs if the agent is found to be enabling reviews not submitted directly by the client.
Realtor.com. Realtor.com agent profiles have displayed ratings and recommendations through third-party survey services. Check Realtor.com’s current terms and your survey vendor’s rules before you import or syndicate reviews.
The practical rule across platforms: the client writes and submits the review on the platform, under their own account, with nothing tied to the rating.
State license law and the Realtor code
Most state license laws do not have a testimonial-specific rule, but every state bans misleading advertising, and testimonials are advertising:
- Georgia bans advertising that is misleading or inaccurate in any material fact or misrepresents services (Rule 520-1-.09), and its definition of media includes websites, social media and email.
- North Carolina requires the firm name in brokerage advertising and bars false or misleading ads (21 NCAC 58A .0105), so a testimonial graphic on social media needs the firm name in the post.
The NAR Code of Ethics, Article 12, requires Realtors to be honest and truthful in real estate communications and to present a true picture in advertising and marketing, and Standard of Practice 12-8 extends that to websites. A testimonial that inflates results, or a review page that hides complaints, can become an ethics complaint as well as an FTC problem. For the state-level picture on advertising, see Fair Housing and Real Estate Advertising Rules by State.
How to ask for reviews the right way
- Ask every closed client. Build one review request into the closing workflow in your CRM so the ask goes to everyone, not only the clients who seem happy.
- Use neutral wording. “Would you share an honest review of working with us?” works. “Leave us 5 stars” does not.
- Link straight to the platform. Send the Google or Zillow link, not a survey that screens the rating first.
- Keep incentives off Google. If you thank clients with a small gift, make it unconditional, give it whether or not they review, and check your state’s rules on gifts.
- No agent-to-agent reviews. Agents should not review each other or the brokerage on public platforms.
- Get written permission for testimonials you reuse in ads or on your website, quote them exactly, and keep the original.
- Answer negative reviews calmly. Reply once, offer to talk offline, and never threaten legal action over an honest review.
- Audit once a year. Remove testimonials from agents who left, clients who withdrew permission, and quotes you cannot source.
Small teams can have a VA or marketing generalist run the request workflow and keep the permission files. The marketing leader owns the policy. If your team is building a broader policy for agents’ online behavior, the free templates include a starting point.
Penalties and enforcement
- Civil penalties. The FTC can seek up to $53,088 per violation for knowing violations of the rule. That is the 2025 inflation-adjusted figure, and it stayed in place for 2026 because the scheduled adjustment was cancelled.
- Warning letters. On December 22, 2025, the FTC sent warning letters to 10 companies it did not name, its first public enforcement step under the rule, and asked them to confirm corrective steps in writing.
- Platform action. Google can remove reviews and restrict or suspend a profile. Zillow can terminate an agent’s profile and programs.
- License and ethics exposure. Misleading testimonials can draw complaints to the state commission or the local Realtor association.
Key takeaways
- The FTC’s Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule has applied since October 21, 2024, with penalties up to $53,088 per violation.
- Fake, purchased and undisclosed insider reviews are banned, and so are incentives tied to positive sentiment.
- Google goes further: no review incentives at all, no review gating and no reviews from employees or competitors.
- Disclose material connections in the review or post itself, including gifts, payments and family ties.
- Ask every closed client the same way, with a direct link to the platform and nothing tied to the rating.
- Treat testimonials as advertising under state license law and Article 12 of the Realtor Code of Ethics.
Sources
Show all 12 sources
- Federal Trade Commission, Final rule banning fake reviews and testimonials (2024) and Federal Register notice
- Federal Trade Commission, The Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers
- eCFR, 16 CFR 465.7 Review suppression
- Federal Register, Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising (2023)
- Federal Trade Commission, Inflation-adjusted civil penalty amounts for 2025 and Federal Register, No adjustment to civil monetary penalty amounts (2026)
- Covington, Inside Privacy, FTC issues warning letters for violations of Consumer Reviews Rule
- Google, Maps user contributed content policy: prohibited and restricted content
- Zillow, How to request client reviews
- Inman, Realtor.com populating agent profiles with third-party reviews (2015)
- Georgia Real Estate Commission, Rule 520-1-.09 Advertising (Cornell LII)
- North Carolina Real Estate Commission, 21 NCAC 58A .0105 Advertising (Cornell LII)
- National Association of Realtors, 2026 Code of Ethics and Standards of Practice
Frequently asked questions
Can we give past clients a gift card for leaving a review?
Under the FTC rule, an incentive is allowed only if it does not depend on the review being positive, and the review should disclose it. Google bans incentives for reviews outright, so do not offer one for Google reviews. Check your state's rules on gifts to clients as well.
Can agents on our team review each other or the brokerage?
Not on Google, which treats reviews by owners, current and former employees and competitors as a conflict of interest. Under the FTC rule, an insider review must clearly disclose the connection, and managers may not push agents to post or collect reviews from relatives without disclosure.
Can we send unhappy clients to a private feedback form instead of Google?
No. Google bans selectively soliciting positive reviews, which is what review gating does. The FTC's staff has said asking only happy customers can also violate the FTC Act. Ask every closed client the same way, and handle complaints separately.
What are the penalties for fake reviews?
The FTC can seek civil penalties of up to $53,088 per violation for knowing violations of the Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule. That figure was set in January 2025 and was not adjusted for 2026. Platforms can also remove reviews or suspend profiles.